{ "tag": [ "compiled" ], "id": "ocds-h6vhtk-0607ff-2026-04-21T14:27:16+01:00", "date": "2026-04-21T14:27:16+01:00", "ocid": "ocds-h6vhtk-0607ff", "initiationType": "tender", "parties": [ { "id": "GB-PPON-PCLC-2366-MYPY", "name": "Places for People Group Limited", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-PPON", "id": "PCLC-2366-MYPY" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "305 Grays Inn Road", "locality": "London", "postalCode": "WC1X 8QR", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKI31" }, "contactPoint": { "name": "Lucy Smith", "email": "ProcurementTeam@placesforpeople.co.uk" }, "roles": [ "buyer" ], "details": { "classifications": [ { "id": "publicAuthoritySubCentralGovernment", "scheme": "UK_CA_TYPE", "description": "Public authority - sub-central government" } ] } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC430614", "name": "Ward Hadaway LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC430614" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "Sandgate House", "locality": "Newcastle Upon Tyne", "postalCode": "NE1 3DX", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKC22" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "bids@wardhadaway.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC319029", "name": "Shakespeare Martineau LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC319029" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "No 1 Colmore Square", "locality": "Birmingham", "postalCode": "B4 6AA", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKG31" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "tenders@shma.co.uk" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC397443", "name": "Osborne Clark LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC397443" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "One London Wall", "locality": "London", "postalCode": "EC2Y 5EB", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKI31" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "bidsteam@osborneclarke.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC317545", "name": "Birketts LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC317545" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "Providence House", "locality": "Ipswich", "postalCode": "IP1 1QJ", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKH14" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "pitches@birketts.co.uk" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC317852", "name": "DAC Beachcroft LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC317852" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "25 Walbrook", "locality": "London", "postalCode": "EC4N 8AF", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKI31" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "bidteam2@dacbeachcroft.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC310010", "name": "Beale and Company Solicitors LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC310010" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "7 Bishopgate", "locality": "London", "postalCode": "EC2N 3AR", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKI31" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "j.kinch@beale-law.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC322045", "name": "Dentons UK and Middle East LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "OC322045" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "One Fleet Place", "locality": "London", "postalCode": "EC4M 7WS", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKI43" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "stacey.fraser@dentons.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-SO301485", "name": "Anderson Strathern LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "SO301485" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "58 Morrison Street", "locality": "Edinburgh", "postalCode": "EH3 8BP", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKM75" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "tenders@andersonstrathern.co.uk" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-SO300472", "name": "Morton Fraser MacRoberts LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "SO300472" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "Level 5, 9 Haymarket Square", "locality": "Edinburgh", "postalCode": "EH3 8RY", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKM75" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "juliet.mcneill@mfmac.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } }, { "id": "GB-COH-SO300380", "name": "Burness Paull LLP", "identifier": { "scheme": "GB-COH", "id": "SO300380" }, "address": { "streetAddress": "50 Lothian Road, Festival Square", "locality": "Edinburgh", "postalCode": "EH3 9WJ", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom", "region": "UKM75" }, "contactPoint": { "email": "bids@burnesspaull.com" }, "roles": [ "supplier", "tenderer" ], "details": { "scale": "large", "vcse": false, "publicServiceMissionOrganization": false, "shelteredWorkshop": false } } ], "buyer": { "id": "GB-PPON-PCLC-2366-MYPY", "name": "Places for People Group Limited" }, "tender": { "id": "ocds-h6vhtk-0607ff", "legalBasis": { "id": "2023/54", "scheme": "UKPGA", "uri": "https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2023/54/contents" }, "title": "Developments Legal Services Framework", "description": "Places for People Group are seeking applications from qualified and experienced legal firms to be appointed to a 4-year framework agreement. The framework agreement will consist of 3 Lots providing legal services for the Developments division of the business, in a cost effective and efficient way for the next 4 years, ending in 2030. This will ensure stability of service delivery and provide an element of cost certainty for the business. The areas of service required will be for England, Wales and Scotland, consequently we have decided to split lots into services based on region. There are 3 lots in total and will consist of: England and Wales - Lot 1- Developments General (5 firms to be appointed) Lot 2- Developments Disputes (3 firms to be appointed) Scotland - Lot 3- Developments General and Disputes (3 firms to be appointed) On all Developments legal services UK wide, we anticipate the value of the contract (based on addressable spend) to be approximately PS7 million (per annum). Further Contracts awarded under the Framework for either Places for People Group companies' members will be awarded in accordance with either the Direct Award or Competitive Award Procedure as described in the Framework Agreement.", "status": "complete", "items": [ { "id": "1", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "relatedLot": "1" }, { "id": "2", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "deliveryAddresses": [ { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" }, { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" } ], "relatedLot": "2" }, { "id": "3", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "deliveryAddresses": [ { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" }, { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" } ], "relatedLot": "3" } ], "value": { "amountGross": 28000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "procurementMethod": "open", "procurementMethodDetails": "Open procedure", "mainProcurementCategory": "services", "aboveThreshold": true, "coveredBy": [ "GPA" ], "participationFees": [ { "id": "ocds-h6vhtk-0607ff", "type": [ "win" ], "description": "N/A" } ], "techniques": { "hasFrameworkAgreement": true, "frameworkAgreement": { "maximumParticipants": 11, "method": "withAndWithoutReopeningCompetition", "type": "closed", "description": "Hourly Rate and Fee Scale" } }, "submissionMethodDetails": "https://placesforpeople.delta-esourcing.com/", "submissionTerms": { "electronicSubmissionPolicy": "allowed", "languages": [ "en" ] }, "tenderPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-02-11T16:00:00+00:00" }, "enquiryPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-02-03T16:00:00+00:00" }, "awardPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-05-01T23:59:59+01:00" }, "lots": [ { "id": "1", "title": "England and Wales Developments General", "description": "It is important to note that the services listed under this lot are designed to be indicative of the types of legal services that will be required but this is not intended to be exhaustive. Lot 1- Developments General (England and Wales) Land acquisition (bare land and serviced parcels) Land disposals (bare land and serviced panels) Land and build contracts for completed or partially completed dwellings (e.g turnkey, golden brick) Bulk sales of complete dwelling or partially completed dwellings, including institutional investor sales (e.g. Private Rented Sector) Strategic Land work Planning matters (e.g. negotiation of planning agreements, strategic planning advice) Dealing with the construction packages for self-delivery schemes to include negotiation of construction contracts, warranties etc. Review of the same on acquisitions from others with vendor build obligations. Plots sales open market Plot sales shared ownership", "status": "complete", "value": { "amountGross": 10000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "awardCriteria": { "criteria": [ { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] } ] }, "suitability": { "sme": true, "vcse": true }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" } }, { "id": "2", "title": "Development Disputes (England and Wales)", "description": "Lot 2- Developments Disputes (England and Wales) Property litigation Construction disputes Supplier disputes Customer care disputes", "status": "complete", "value": { "amountGross": 9000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "awardCriteria": { "criteria": [ { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] } ] }, "suitability": { "sme": true, "vcse": true }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" } }, { "id": "3", "title": "Developments General and Legal (Scotland)", "description": "Lot 3- Developments General and Disputes (Scotland) Land acquisition (bare land and serviced parcels) Land disposals (bare land and serviced panels) Land and build contracts for completed or partially completed dwellings (e.g turnkey, golden brick) Bulk sales of complete dwelling or partially completed dwellings, including institutional investor sales (e.g. Private Rented Sector) Strategic Land work Planning matters (e.g. negotiation of planning agreements, strategic planning advice) Dealing with the construction packages for self-delivery schemes to include negotiation of construction contracts, warranties etc. Review of the same on acquisitions from others with vendor build obligations. Plots sales open market Plot sales shared equity Property litigation Construction disputes Supplier disputes Customer care disputes", "status": "complete", "value": { "amountGross": 9000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "awardCriteria": { "criteria": [ { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "quality", "name": "Quality and Technical Merit", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 60, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] }, { "type": "price", "name": "Pricing", "description": "Percentage", "numbers": [ { "number": 40, "weight": "percentageExact" } ] } ] }, "suitability": { "sme": true, "vcse": true }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" } } ], "documents": [ { "id": "conflictOfInterest", "documentType": "conflictOfInterest", "description": "Not published" }, { "id": "004049-2026", "documentType": "tenderNotice", "noticeType": "UK4", "description": "Tender notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/004049-2026", "datePublished": "2026-01-16T16:06:23Z", "format": "text/html" }, { "id": "004976-2026", "documentType": "tenderNotice", "noticeType": "UK4", "description": "Tender notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/004976-2026", "datePublished": "2026-01-20T16:05:36Z", "format": "text/html" }, { "id": "036151-2026", "documentType": "tenderCancellationNotice", "noticeType": "UK12", "description": "Procurement termination notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/036151-2026", "datePublished": "2026-04-21T14:27:16+01:00", "format": "text/html" } ], "amendments": [ { "id": "004976-2026", "description": "In the questionnaire, the following changes have been made to the tenderbox; Added section to upload the documents. As a result, we have closed the original tenderbox, for the new tenderbox please follow the below link. https://placesforpeople.delta-esourcing.com/respond/PPH3499AW9" } ] }, "language": "en", "bids": { "details": [ { "id": "1", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC430614", "name": "Ward Hadaway LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "1" ] }, { "id": "2", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC319029", "name": "Shakespeare Martineau LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "1" ] }, { "id": "3", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC397443", "name": "Osborne Clark LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "1", "2" ] }, { "id": "4", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC317545", "name": "Birketts LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "1" ] }, { "id": "5", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC317852", "name": "DAC Beachcroft LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "1" ] }, { "id": "6", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC310010", "name": "Beale and Company Solicitors LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "2" ] }, { "id": "7", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC322045", "name": "Dentons UK and Middle East LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "2" ] }, { "id": "8", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-SO301485", "name": "Anderson Strathern LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "3" ] }, { "id": "9", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-SO300472", "name": "Morton Fraser MacRoberts LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "3" ] }, { "id": "10", "status": "valid", "tenderers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-SO300380", "name": "Burness Paull LLP" } ], "relatedLots": [ "3" ] } ], "statistics": [ { "id": "1", "measure": "bids", "value": 35, "relatedLot": "1" }, { "id": "2", "measure": "bids", "value": 28, "relatedLot": "2" }, { "id": "3", "measure": "bids", "value": 6, "relatedLot": "3" }, { "id": "4", "measure": "finalStageBids", "value": 5, "relatedLot": "1" }, { "id": "5", "measure": "smeFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "1" }, { "id": "6", "measure": "vcseFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "1" }, { "id": "7", "measure": "finalStageBids", "value": 3, "relatedLot": "2" }, { "id": "8", "measure": "smeFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "2" }, { "id": "9", "measure": "vcseFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "2" }, { "id": "10", "measure": "finalStageBids", "value": 3, "relatedLot": "3" }, { "id": "11", "measure": "smeFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "3" }, { "id": "12", "measure": "vcseFinalStageBids", "value": 0, "relatedLot": "3" } ] }, "awards": [ { "id": "1", "title": "England and Wales Developments General", "status": "cancelled", "date": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "value": { "amountGross": 10000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "mainProcurementCategory": "services", "aboveThreshold": true, "suppliers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC430614", "name": "Ward Hadaway LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC319029", "name": "Shakespeare Martineau LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC397443", "name": "Osborne Clark LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC317545", "name": "Birketts LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC317852", "name": "DAC Beachcroft LLP" } ], "items": [ { "id": "1", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "deliveryAddresses": [ { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" } ], "relatedLot": "1" } ], "standstillPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-04-23T23:59:59+01:00" }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" }, "relatedLots": [ "1" ], "documents": [ { "id": "033532-2026", "documentType": "awardNotice", "noticeType": "UK6", "description": "Contract award notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/033532-2026", "datePublished": "2026-04-14T09:10:37+01:00", "format": "text/html" } ], "assessmentSummariesDateSent": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "milestones": [ { "id": "1", "type": "futureSignatureDate", "dueDate": "2026-05-01T23:59:59+01:00", "status": "scheduled" } ], "statusDetails": "During the standstill period, matters were brought to our attention which led to a review of the procurement procedure. That review identified issues which gave rise to concerns on PfP's part as to the procedure followed. In light of these concerns, PfP has determined that the best course of action is to terminate the procurement. A notice to that effect will be published shortly in accordance with s.55 of the Act and regulation 37 of the Procurement Regulations 2024. PfP intends to re-procure these services in due course and we hope that this decision will not deter you from participating in that process.", "finalStatusDate": "2026-04-21T00:00:00+01:00" }, { "id": "2", "title": "Development Disputes (England and Wales)", "status": "cancelled", "date": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "value": { "amountGross": 9000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "mainProcurementCategory": "services", "aboveThreshold": true, "suppliers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-OC397443", "name": "Osborne Clark LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC310010", "name": "Beale and Company Solicitors LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-OC322045", "name": "Dentons UK and Middle East LLP" } ], "items": [ { "id": "2", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "deliveryAddresses": [ { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" } ], "relatedLot": "2" } ], "standstillPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-04-23T23:59:59+01:00" }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" }, "relatedLots": [ "2" ], "documents": [ { "id": "033532-2026", "documentType": "awardNotice", "noticeType": "UK6", "description": "Contract award notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/033532-2026", "datePublished": "2026-04-14T09:10:37+01:00", "format": "text/html" } ], "assessmentSummariesDateSent": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "milestones": [ { "id": "2", "type": "futureSignatureDate", "dueDate": "2026-05-01T23:59:59+01:00", "status": "scheduled" } ], "statusDetails": "During the standstill period, matters were brought to our attention which led to a review of the procurement procedure. That review identified issues which gave rise to concerns on PfP's part as to the procedure followed. In light of these concerns, PfP has determined that the best course of action is to terminate the procurement. A notice to that effect will be published shortly in accordance with s.55 of the Act and regulation 37 of the Procurement Regulations 2024. PfP intends to re-procure these services in due course and we hope that this decision will not deter you from participating in that process.", "finalStatusDate": "2026-04-21T00:00:00+01:00" }, { "id": "3", "title": "Developments General and Legal (Scotland)", "status": "cancelled", "date": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "value": { "amountGross": 9000000, "currency": "GBP" }, "mainProcurementCategory": "services", "aboveThreshold": true, "suppliers": [ { "id": "GB-COH-SO301485", "name": "Anderson Strathern LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-SO300472", "name": "Morton Fraser MacRoberts LLP" }, { "id": "GB-COH-SO300380", "name": "Burness Paull LLP" } ], "items": [ { "id": "3", "additionalClassifications": [ { "scheme": "CPV", "id": "79100000", "description": "Legal services" } ], "deliveryAddresses": [ { "region": "UK", "country": "GB", "countryName": "United Kingdom" } ], "relatedLot": "3" } ], "standstillPeriod": { "endDate": "2026-04-23T23:59:59+01:00" }, "contractPeriod": { "startDate": "2026-05-01T00:00:00+01:00", "endDate": "2030-04-30T23:59:59+01:00" }, "relatedLots": [ "3" ], "documents": [ { "id": "033532-2026", "documentType": "awardNotice", "noticeType": "UK6", "description": "Contract award notice on Find a Tender", "url": "https://www.find-tender.service.gov.uk/Notice/033532-2026", "datePublished": "2026-04-14T09:10:37+01:00", "format": "text/html" } ], "assessmentSummariesDateSent": "2026-04-14T00:00:00+01:00", "milestones": [ { "id": "3", "type": "futureSignatureDate", "dueDate": "2026-05-01T23:59:59+01:00", "status": "scheduled" } ], "statusDetails": "During the standstill period, matters were brought to our attention which led to a review of the procurement procedure. That review identified issues which gave rise to concerns on PfP's part as to the procedure followed. In light of these concerns, PfP has determined that the best course of action is to terminate the procurement. A notice to that effect will be published shortly in accordance with s.55 of the Act and regulation 37 of the Procurement Regulations 2024. PfP intends to re-procure these services in due course and we hope that this decision will not deter you from participating in that process.", "finalStatusDate": "2026-04-21T00:00:00+01:00" } ] }